Ultimate Peanut Butter Cheesecake
If you love peanut butter and cheesecake, you are going to love the ULTIMATE Peanut Butter Cheesecake! With a Nutter Butter crust, swirls of melted chocolate and peanut butter, and dollops of fluffy whipped cream, this is the perfect celebratory dessert for the peanut butter lovers in your life!
Hello, peanut butter lovers! Do I have the recipe for you!
If you love peanut butter and you love cheesecake, you need (yes, need!) this in your life.
This isn’t just any old peanut butter cheesecake. It’s the ultimate peanut butter cheesecake.
What does that mean? It means we’ve jam-packed all the peanut butter we can into this creamy, dreamy, silky, delicious cheesecake.
Forget a graham cracker crust — we’re doing a Nutter Butter crust. With extra Nutter Butters on top, of course.
And whipped cream swirls, because every dessert is made better with whipped cream swirls!
If you’re new to making cheesecakes, don’t worry – you can make this! Read on for all the step-by-step instructions for a perfect cheesecake every time!
Nutter Butter Cookie Crust
Yes, you can do a graham cracker crust or an Oreo crust. (Chocolate and peanut butter IS a winning combination, after all.)
Buuuuut we’re packing this full of the most peanut butter flavor possible, which means a nutter butter cookie crust!
If you’re not familiar with Nutter Butters, they’re peanut butter sandwich cookies – peanut butter flavored cookies filled with a peanut butter filling. Think Oreos, but all peanut butter.
If you can’t find Nutter Butters, substitute any peanut butter sandwich cookie, or use regular peanut butter cookies.
To make the crust, crush the cookies into a fine, sand-like consistency. Mix with melted butter, press into a springform pan, and bake.
Creamiest Peanut Butter Filling
Let’s talk about getting the best texture AND flavor out of the peanut butter cheesecake itself.
We’re going to include all the usual suspects in my many cheesecake recipes: cream cheese, sour cream, and eggs.
This time, we have a few extra additions. Peanut butter, of course – it is a peanut butter cheesecake, after all! And brown sugar, in lieu of the traditional granulated sugar. This adds an extra peanut butter cookie-ish flavor to the cheesecake. Finally, we’re also adding one extra egg yolk to the eggs, for an even creamier texture.
One tip that makes a huge difference in both texture and flavor? Use commercial peanut butter, not natural (the kind that separates and requires stirring). Why? It’s time for my favorite subject… kitchen chemistry!
Commercial peanut butters undergo a homogenization process, which adds a stabilizer to the ground peanuts to eliminate the separation of oils. Because of this homogenization, commercial peanut butter will not separate out after temperature fluctuations, unlike natural peanut butter.
So why does this matter? Natural peanut butter will separate out as the cheesecake bakes and then chills, resulting in patches of oil and a grittier texture.
Once the cheesecake is baked and cooled, it should be stored in the refrigerator for up to a week.
There are often water droplets that settle on the top of the cheesecake after refrigeration. This is normal and due to condensation. Use a paper towel to gently press on the surface of the cheesecake to absorb any of the water.
Cheesecakes also freeze beautifully and are a perfect make-ahead dessert!
To freeze the whole cheesecake, leave off the whipped cream and decorative Nutter Butters. Refrigerate until chilled, then wrap the entire cheesecake in a layer of plastic wrap and a layer of aluminum foil. Freeze for up to 3 months. To use, thaw in the refrigerator and add the whipped cream and nutter butters before serving.
Individual slices of cheesecake can also be frozen. Place cut slices on a cookie sheet and freeze until the whipped cream on top is solid. Wrap each slice in plastic wrap, followed by a layer of aluminum foil, and store in a freezer bag. Unwrap each slice before thawing in the refrigerator.
Tips and Tricks for the Best Peanut Butter Cheesecake
- Use all room temperature ingredients! If the cream cheese is too firm, the batter will not be smooth and the resulting lumps are likely to cause cracks.
- Don’t overmix the batter! Overmixing adds additional air, which can also lead to cracks in the cheesecake. Always keep the mixer speed on low.
- Scrape the sides of the bowl frequently while mixing. This ensures all ingredients are well mixed and no pockets of cream cheese are left in the bottom of the bowl.
- Bake the cheesecake in a water bath. The water bath creates additional steam which keeps the texture creamy and helps prevent cracking. Either wrap the springform pan with several layers of aluminum foil and place this inside a pan full of water, or place the 9-inch springform pan inside a 10-inch round cake pan, and then place both together inside a larger pan filled with water.
- Bake until there is a 2-3 inch diameter circle in the center which is still very jiggly. Alternatively, use an instant-read thermometer and bake until the cheesecake reaches an internal temperature of 145 °F.
- Cool slowly and gently. Abrupt changes in temperature cause a cheesecake to deflate and rack. Turn off the oven, leave the door open an inch, and let the cheesecake cool.
More Peanut Butter Recipes
- Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana Pretzel Pie
- No Bake Oreo Peanut Butter Pie
- Peanut Butter Stuffed Brownies
- Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Bundt Cake
- Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake Dip
- Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cake
- All Peanut Butter Recipes ≫
2022 Cheesecake of the Month Series
For the Crust:
- 30 Nutter Butter peanut butter sandwich cookies cookies
- 6 tablespoons (85 grams) unsalted butter, melted
For the Cheesecake:
- 32 ounces (908 grams) cream cheese, room temperature
- 1 cup (270 grams) creamy peanut butter
- 1/2 cup (113 grams) sour cream, room temperature
- 1 1/4 cups (266 grams) brown sugar, packed
- 3/4 teaspoon kosher salt
- 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
- 4 large eggs plus 1 egg yolk, room temperature
For the Whipped Cream:
- 3/4 cup (170 grams) heavy cream
- 2 tablespoons confectioners' sugar
- 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 8 Nutter Butter cookies
- 1/4 cup (42 grams) chocolate chips (optional)
- 1/4 cup peanut butter chips (optional)
- Make the crust. Preheat oven to 350 °F. Add Nutter Butters to a food processor and chop or crush into fine crumbs by hand. Pour in melted butter and mix using the food processor. Press the crumbs along the bottom and extend up the sides of a 9-inch springform pan, compacting the crumbs as much as possible. Bake for 10 minutes, then remove from oven. Reduce oven temperature to 325 °F.
- Make the cheesecake. Using an electric mixer with the whisk attachment, beat together the cream cheese and peanut butter until smooth and well combined, 2 to 3 minutes. Mix in the sour cream, brown sugar, salt, and vanilla extract, stirring until well combined. Crack the four eggs plus one extra egg yolk into a small bowl and mix with a fork to break up the yolks. Slowly pour roughly a quarter of the eggs into the cream cheese mixture, mix to combine, and repeat until all eggs are added. Do not over-mix the cheesecake - this makes it more likely to crack. Using a rubber spatula, scrape down the sides and along the bottom of the bowl several times while mixing ingredients.
- Prepare the springform pan. Wrap the springform pan in 3 layers of aluminum foil, or create a pan-in-pan water bath (recommended) by placing the 9-inch springform pan inside a 10-inch cake pan (both pans together will be placed inside the water bath). Pour the cheesecake batter into the prepared Nutter Butter crust.
- Bake the cheesecake. Place the springform pan inside a larger pan with high sides and pour in hot water until the water level comes approximately halfway up the sides of the springform pan (or the outer cake pan). Bake at 325 °F for 60 to 70 minutes, or until the edges have set but a 3-inch diameter circle in the center of the cheesecake still jiggles. Turn off the oven and open the door slightly; cool in the warm oven for 30 minutes. After 30 minutes, remove the cheesecake from the oven and let it sit at room temperature for 1 hour before placing in the refrigerator to chill for at least 4 hours, preferably overnight.
- Make the whipped cream. Once the cheesecake has cooled, make the whipped cream. Using a hand mixer, stand mixer, or immersion blender with a whisk attachment, whisk together the heavy cream, confectioners' sugar, and vanilla extract until stiff peaks form.
- Decorate the cheesecake. If desired, melt the chocolate chips in the microwave and drizzle the melted chocolate around the edges of the cheesecake. Repeat with the peanut butter chips. Pipe the whipped cream onto the cheesecake and decorate with the additional Nutter Butter cookies.
- Use room temperature ingredients to ensure proper mixing with no lumps.
- Mix the batter thoroughly, but do not overmix or mix on high speed which incorporates additional air into the batter.
- Scrape the sides and bottom of the bowl frequently while mixing the batter.
- Bake until the center of the cheesecake still jiggles, or reaches a temperature of 145 °F on an instant-read thermometer.
Cheesecake can be refrigerated for up to 5 days or frozen for up to 3 months.
As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.