Cake Mix Hamantaschen
Love making hamantaschen but want to shorten the process? This cake mix hamantaschen dough recipe tastes like the real deal, but only takes 3 minutes to mix. Perfect for baking with kids, too!
Purim is this week, which means it’s time for the most delicious of all holiday-themed cookies: hamantaschen!
A few years ago, I shared a delicious, easy, made entirely-from-scratch traditional homemade hamataschen dough recipe. It rolls out like a dream, is easy to fold over, and stays closed while you bake it.
Buuuuut I also mentioned that the recipe wasn’t quite what I was looking to replicate.
I have spent years (YEARS! DECADES! MY ENTIRE ADULT LIFE!) trying to replicate the hamantaschen from my childhood — these giant, artificially yellow-ish, super crumbly, much more cake-like than cookie-like, perfectly triangular hamantaschen.
So when my mother said this year, she made hamantaschen from a cake mix I was super excited. I generally prefer to bake from scratch, but how better to replicate cakey hamantaschen than using a cake mix?
(Spoiler alert: this was not the cakey hamantaschen recipe of my dreams, which I am convinced may not really exist. Perhaps I am misremembering?)
But, what we have here, is a very good, very easy recipe, that is not entirely too dissimilar from my traditional homemade hamantaschen recipe, except the dough rolls a little thinner.
And also, it’s made from cake mix, so it’s the PERFECT solution to those of you who want hamantaschen but aren’t super into baking from scratch. Or the perfect first hamantaschen for little bakers – this is such an easy “cooking with kids” recipe!
Yes, this is made from cake mix — I see you baking purists shuddering. But it also takes like three minutes to make the dough, and then you get to the fun part: filling and folding.
Let’s back up a second first, though. Purim? Hamantaschen? What’s all this about?
What are Hamantaschen?
Hamantaschen are a triangular-shaped cookie associated with the Jewish holiday Purim. At Purim, we celebrate when Esther triumphed over the evil vizier Haman, who tried to destroy all the Jews.
To make the classic three-cornered shape, cookies are rolled into a circle, a small amount of filling is placed in the center, and the sides are folded (or pinched) up around the filling to create a little triangular pocket.
Why are they called hamantaschen?
We eat hamantaschen on Purim (which falls in late winter/early spring) because, like so many things in Judaism, it’s tradition! But what’s the root of this tradition? There are lots of different theories…
The most obvious, of course, is the reference to Haman in the name hamantaschen. The three corned triangular shape is thought to be a reference to the three-cornered hat worn by Haman (and my 3 year old now likes to call them hat cookies). Tash in Hebrew means weakened — a nod to God weakening Haman to allow his defeat. Haman-taschen, thus meaning Haman was weakened.
Another theory, however, goes to the Yiddish root of the word: mohn meaning poppy (which is the classic filling) and tasche meaning pocket. A poppy-filled pocket cookie! Ooooor maybe the pocket reference is because Haman offered to pay money — emptying his pockets — to the king to receive permission to kill the Jews.
How to make cake mix hamantaschen
Hamantaschen are a little more involved than most cookies because of rolling out and filling the dough. So in order to make things super duper extremely easy, cake mix hamantaschen start with a box of cake mix.
All you need to add to the cake mix is flour, vegetable oil, eggs, and a little water. That’s it!
Mix together all the ingredients, by hand or with a mixer, until a stiff dough forms. No need to refrigerate the dough like my classic recipe; this dough is stiff enough that you can roll it right away.
Lightly flour your working surface and roll the dough out to 1/8th-inch. Use a round cookie cutter to cut the dough into 3-inch circles. Place a teaspoon of filling into the center of the dough, then fold (or pinch — I tried both methods to confirm it would work for everyone’s preferences) the sides up into a triangle.
Tips for Perfect Hamantaschen
Now that we have making the dough down, how do we ensure the filling stays put? Here are my top tips for ensuring your cake mix hamantaschen (or any hamantaschen!) stay closed with the filling inside.
- Use a thick filling. I’ll talk more about fillings below, but the goal is to use something thick enough that it won’t bubble over or run down the sides. If you’re using a thinner filling — something cream cheese based, for example — refrigerate the filling first to firm it up, then spoon some into the center. If you scoop the filling, it’s good — if you have to spoon and pour it because it’s liquidy, it’s too thin.
- Use at least a 3-inch cookie cutter for the dough. You can go bigger (and who doesn’t like bigger cookies?!), but don’t go smaller. The smaller the circle, the harder it is to seal the dough on the corners.
- Pinch or fold corners well and seal with water if necessary. One of the things I like about this cake mix dough is that it’s stiff enough that I didn’t need a little water to hold the corners shut. But if you find they are popping open, dip your finger in a little water and run it over the dough to help seal the corners shut.
- Don’t overfill your hamantaschen! I know it’s tempting because the filling is delicious, but too much filling will spill down the sides while it bakes (especially true for things that rise while baking – like a brownie batter filling). One to one and a half teaspoons are all you need for a 3-inch circle!
- Chill the cookies before baking. After rolling the dough and forming the hamantaschen, transfer the baking sheet to the refrigerator and chill for 15-20 minutes. The cold dough is less likely to spread or unfold while baking.
What do you use for hamantaschen filling?
In this day and age, anything goes! The traditional filling is poppy, but apricot and prune are also classics.
From here, other fruit flavors started popping up: any variety of jam or preserve. These are my personal favorites, and I consider Purim to be the perfect opportunity to go through my refrigerator cupboards and find what various jars of jam and fruit preserves we’ve collected over the past few months.
For this batch, I used some lemon curd (because I love lemon curd), apple butter (from a random jar that I realized we would never otherwise open), and orange marmalade (leftover from making this Instant Pot Orange Chicken). The lemon curd are delicious but the apple butter were the surprise winners in my book. I even made an extra two dozen to bring to my son’s preschool class!
Nowadays, if it’s a thick enough filling, people have added it to hamantaschen. Brownie batter. Nutella. Mint chocolate chip. Blueberry goat cheese. It’s all in there.
In fact, The Nosher has an “Ultimate Ranking of Hamantaschen Fillings” in which they suggest s’mores filling. You guys know I love everything s’mores (see: s’mores cookie cake, s’mores pie, gooey s’mores bars, s’mores bundt cake, small batch s’mores brownies) so I think I know what I’m trying next year!
How to store hamantaschen
Because of the filling, hamantaschen have a shorter shelf life than most cookies. They are best consumed within the first two day. After three days the cookie starts to get a bit soggy from the filling (particularly with fruit fillings).
Allow the hamantaschen to cool completely on a wire rack, then transfer to an air-tight storage container. Keep at room temperature for up to three days.
How to freeze hamantaschen
One of the best parts of hamantaschen: they can be made ahead of time!
Either hamantaschen dough, or the fully baked cookies, can be frozen. With this fast three minute cake mix hamantaschen, it doesn’t really make sense to freeze a batch of dough. The whole hamantaschen, however — what a perfect way to get Purim prep done ahead of time (or save some from your Purim batch to enjoy year round!).
Hamantaschen can be stored at room temperature in an airtight container for 3 days. To freeze, place fully cooled cookies in a plastic freezer bag and store for up to 3 months. Thaw at room temperature before eating. As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Nutrition Information: Yield: 28 Serving Size: 1 cookie
Amount Per Serving: Calories: 154 Total Fat: 3.1g Carbohydrates: 29.8g Protein: 1.6g
Hamantaschen can be stored at room temperature in an airtight container for 3 days. To freeze, place fully cooled cookies in a plastic freezer bag and store for up to 3 months. Thaw at room temperature before eating.
As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.